Dead last in digital ed

California is a backwater for K-12 online learning, according to a new analysis of states’ policies toward virtual education. Other states are clearing away obstacles and adopting innovative strategies, such as allowing middle school students to take high school courses online and letting students start online courses anytime and complete them whenever they show competency. California is stuck in the past, imposing the standard calendar and student-teacher ratios on a virtual world.

At least that’s the implication of Digital Learning Now! – a project of the Foundation for Excellence in Education, headed by former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, and the Alliance for Excellent Education, a nonprofit headed by former Democratic Gov. Bob Wise of West Virginia. California scored at the bottom of the 72-point rubric, which was released at the Foundation’s conference in San Francisco last week.

With recent reports out of Colorado and Minnesota showing students in virtual schools significantly underperforming their peers, California can certainly wonder whether it’s smart to rush headlong into this brave new world, as Utah has done. Caution may be the watchword.

And some of the many measurements that Digital Learning Now chose are suspect, according to Eric Premack, executive director and founder of the Charter Schools Development Center in Sacramento. But Premack, who has counseled online schools through state regs, has long advocated loosening some of the restrictions limiting expansion and experimentation in online education. These include restrictive student-teacher ratios for online independent study schools and, for blended learning schools that combine online studying and classroom instruction, the imposition of a minimum number of minutes of daily instruction by certificated teachers. The latter rule limits the ability of successful schools, like Rocketship Education, to expand their learning labs beyond a quarter of the day.

Premack adds another inhibitor not covered by Digital Learning Now!, the reluctance of the University of California to qualify high school online courses as satisfying A-G requirements for admission to a UC or CSU campus.

California was redundantly dinged in the scoring for its requirement that an online operator can only open a school in a county and adjacent counties. While the national for-profit online operator, K12, Inc., has opened enough online charter schools to cover the large population areas in California, not every student in the state has access to online offerings, one of the criteria. The alternative, as in Florida, is for the state to open a statewide online school. Premack argues that California’s geographical requirement encourages innovation.

Last year, Bush and Wise came up with 10 elements of high-quality digital learning. They are:

  • Student Access: All students are digital learners.
  • Barriers to Access: All students have access to high-quality digital learning.
  • Personalized Learning: All students can use digital learning to customize their education.
  • Advancement: All students progress based on demonstrated competency.
  • Quality Content: Digital content and courses are high quality.
  • Quality Instruction: Digital instruction is high quality.
  • Quality Choices: All students have access to multiple high-quality digital providers.
  • Assessment and Accountability: Student learning is the metric for evaluating the quality of content and instruction.
  • Funding: Funding creates incentives for performance, options, and innovation.
  • Infrastructure: Infrastructure supports digital learning.

Over the past year, they developed 72 measures of the elements. Go here for California’s scorecard. Some, like a law requiring that all students be equipped with an Internet access device, are aspirational. A few, reflecting Bush’s conservative politics, are ideological: e.g., extending publicly funded digital learning to private school students. And some are innovative, worth experimenting with, such as tying funding for online schools to student performance, the passage of an end-of-year exam.

There is nothing in state law to prevent school districts from charging ahead with blended learning, as done by Rocketship and the new Silicon Valley Flex Academy. Bureaucracy and anxiety over the unknown are the chief obstacles. The state also has freed up textbook money to permit districts to purchases digital materials.

If anything, the new scorecard should prompt state officials to look around at what other states are beginning to do – and to start to experiment with the good ideas.

Note: Digital Learning Now! did not rank the states. But you can do state-by-state comparisons on this interactive map. And Brian Bridges, director of the California Learning Resource Network (CLRN) and a font of knowledge on digital courses, did calculate the states’ individual totals. Out of a possible score of 72, Utah and Wyoming topped the states with 49. The median was 27, he reports in his blog. With 14 points, California was last.

Author: John Fensterwald - Educated Guess

John Fensterwald, a journalist at the Silicon Valley Education Foundation, edits and co-writes "Thoughts on Public Education in California" (www.TOPed.org), one of the leading sources of California education policy reporting and opinion, which he founded in 2009. For 11 years before that, John wrote editorials for the Mercury News in San Jose, with a focus on education. He worked as a reporter, news editor and opinion editor for three newspapers in New Hampshire for two decades before receiving a Knight Fellowship at Stanford University in 1997 and heading West shortly thereafter. His wife is an elementary school teacher and his daughter attends the University California at Davis.

1,017 thoughts on “Dead last in digital ed”

  1. e2 investor visa specialists|we like it cialis info|apotheke cialis 10mg|best way buy cialis online|cialis guenstig|cialis gnrique tadalafil 10 mg|cialis money order india|cialis 36 horas|cialis ou levitra|cialis not generic buy|cialis buy nz|cialis rythme cardiaque|cialis ibuprofen|i recommend best pharma cialis|follow link uk cialis sales|cialis farmacia svizzer|cialis ben moren|low price cialis 200mg|prescripcin cialis en u s|women reviews cialis|commander cialis generique|cialis dosage france|just try cialis canadian|generic cialis directions|discount soft cialis|look here cialis for daily use|cialis generico senza ricetta|cialis 5 mg come funziona|cialis 5mg medicament|best prices or cialis|cialis professional discount|look there best place cialis|preis cialis 20|cialis professional kaufen|cialis bas pri|the best place cialis tablet|link for you cialis for men|cialis 5 mg diario preci|best cialis prices|cialis brand for cheap|only now next day cialis|to cialis best take|cialis 20mg lilly erfahrung|cialis 5 or 10mg|generic cialis 20mg nl|40mg cialis huge erection|the best site women cialis|cialis 20 mg coupon discounts|cialis apotheke polen|how often can i take cialis|where is cheapest cialis|generique cialis interne|cialis 5 mg cost walgreens|cialis 20 mg tablet|cialis professional 20 pills|canadian made generic cialis|erfahrungen cialis forum|cialis lowest prices|cialis 5 mg cura prostata|sconto australiano cialis|generique du cialis|cialis for men and women|new cialis for sale|tomar cialis 20 mg|cialis de 40 mg|cialis generic store cipla|cialis canada rx users group|cialis farmacie online|cialis 50mg side effects|cialis generico bugiardino|cialis tadalafi|cialis y otros|cialis generico sicuro online|prix cialis generique|uk soft tab cialis online|cialis compra usa|cialis cheap 20|cialis australia generic|cialis quick shipment|cialis brand prices|achat de cialis gnrique|cialis 20mg en belgique|take generic cialis|only today cialis generic sale|were to buy cialis online|cialis per nachname bestellen|cialis for sale in cebu|we like it buy cialis generic|about the socialist project|click now low cost cialis|how to take generic cialis|cialis dosage average|click here gerenic cialis|cialis does insurance my|cialis levitra propecia|discount cialis generic cheap|buy cialis aus|brand cialis buy online|visit web site buy cialis us|only best offers find cialis|cialis price per pill 2013|canadian healthcare cialis|cheapest cialis nz|cialis precio farmacia mexico|cialis tadalafil delivery|10203050100 mg cialis|cmprar cialis genericos|can cialis cause weight loss|buy cialis 50|cialis beipackzettel|discount 10 mg generic cialis|cialis online 2 day shipping|cialis deutschland apotheke|cialis reduzierte preis|purchase cialis 5 mg online|cialis 10 o 2|cialis compresse 5 mg prezzo|cialis with priligy|quanto costa cialis da 10 mg|cialis online bestellen wo|cialis safety|i recommend online meds cialis|24 pharmacy cialis|good choice cialis 100mg|brand 10mg cialis price|cialis buy cheap best|cialis generico en colombi|bonuses cialis pharmacy online|cialis generico postepay|generic cialis chewable|cheap 2 5 mg cialis|cialis haltbarkeit|legal buy cialis online|prix du cialis canada|cialis originale italia|good choice cheap cialis 50mg|we like it 5mg cialis generic|generika cialis oral jelly| cialis surrey bc|como comprar cialis en india|enter site buy generic cialis|daily use cialis|20 mg cialis cost|10mg or 20mg cialis|cialis tadalafil 80mg|cialis new york times|preis cialis once a da|usefull link ordering cialis|i recommend cialis cheap buy|cialis generico india|cialis tadalafil kosten|cialis generico en torreon|cialis farmacia acquisto|try it cialis online store|online pharmacy cialis c 40|fast delivery cialis sweden|where can i order cialis cheap|wow next day cialis|cialis 10 mg en andorra|prezzi di cialis uk|cheapest generic cialis soft|is 200mg of cialis too strong|cialis cancer de la prostate|cheap cialis from usa|donde comprar cialis en espa|order cialis online australia|cialis mexico online|discount cialis 32|100mg cialis to buy in uk|cialis usa online paypal|donde comprar cialis 5 mg|best prices for cialis online|just try cheap fast cialis|cialis strips online|enter site rx cialis low price|cialis prix farmacias lila|look there cialis delivery|only now buy cialis uk|discounted cialis online|only here cialis dosage|cialis generique en pharmacie|purchase brand cialis in uk|cialis generic cialis|cialis canadian pharmacy buy|cialis levitra ebay|buy cialis from estonia|cialis dosage sale|cialis and grapefruit juice|buy cialis 25 mg buy now|cialis alle donne|comprar cialis en colombia|usefull link cialis on line|cialis acheter internet|acheter cialis ligne france|cialis omeprazolo|lilly cialis onlin|buy female cialis with paypal|cialis 100mg canada|prix du cialis 5mg en france|cialis non v|precio de cialis en uk|cialis 10 mg espaa|cialis cheapest price 5mg|cialis super acti|compre la pastilla cialis|daily cialis when to take|cialis tabs wholesale|tabs of cialis generic|comprar cialis espaa|cheap cialis on line 5 mg|cialis tadalafil 20mg original|cialis generika 20mg|cialis i migliori|a half cialis 20mg|how much does cialis costs|cialis coupon walmart|cialis fast delivery europe|where to buy generic cialis|levitra sale walmart cialis|cialis eli lilly|side effects of cialis for men|cialis 10 mg daily|cialis 10mg online bestellen|cialis online preise|purchase discount cialis|acquisto cialis reato|generic cialis soft|cialis 20 mg rezept|cialis for sale|we use it get cialis online|buy cialis tennessee online|cialis fast delivery no doctor|come funziona il cialis 20 mg|only for you get cialis online|cialis generique 20 mg|free cialis trial online|medikament cialis 20|american cialis paypal|generic cialis trial size|cipla cialis order|cialis cheap from india|achat cialis en ligne europe|look here cialis 30 mg|price cialis 5 best australia|cialis et tension|qualitygenerics comcialis|cialis mdicament|does cialis work on women|cost of cialis vs levitra|looking for cialis cheap

    [url=http://cialishde.com/]cialis canada,canadian cialis,cialis,buy cialis,generic cialis online,generic cialis,cialis cheap,cialis online,buy cialis,cialis[/url]
    cialis canada,canadian cialis,cialis,buy cialis,generic cialis online,generic cialis,cialis cheap,cialis online,buy cialis,cialis

    e2 investor visa specialists|we like it cialis info|apotheke cialis 10mg|best way buy cialis online|cialis guenstig|cialis gnrique tadalafil 10 mg|cialis money order india|cialis 36 horas|cialis ou levitra|cialis not generic buy|cialis buy nz|cialis rythme cardiaque|cialis ibuprofen|i recommend best pharma cialis|follow link uk cialis sales|cialis farmacia svizzer|cialis ben moren|low price cialis 200mg|prescripcin cialis en u s|women reviews cialis|commander cialis generique|cialis dosage france|just try cialis canadian|generic cialis directions|discount soft cialis|look here cialis for daily use|cialis generico senza ricetta|cialis 5 mg come funziona|cialis 5mg medicament|best prices or cialis|cialis professional discount|look there best place cialis|preis cialis 20|cialis professional kaufen|cialis bas pri|the best place cialis tablet|link for you cialis for men|cialis 5 mg diario preci|best cialis prices|cialis brand for cheap|only now next day cialis|to cialis best take|cialis 20mg lilly erfahrung|cialis 5 or 10mg|generic cialis 20mg nl|40mg cialis huge erection|the best site women cialis|cialis 20 mg coupon discounts|cialis apotheke polen|how often can i take cialis|where is cheapest cialis|generique cialis interne|cialis 5 mg cost walgreens|cialis 20 mg tablet|cialis professional 20 pills|canadian made generic cialis|erfahrungen cialis forum|cialis lowest prices|cialis 5 mg cura prostata|sconto australiano cialis|generique du cialis|cialis for men and women|new cialis for sale|tomar cialis 20 mg|cialis de 40 mg|cialis generic store cipla|cialis canada rx users group|cialis farmacie online|cialis 50mg side effects|cialis generico bugiardino|cialis tadalafi|cialis y otros|cialis generico sicuro online|prix cialis generique|uk soft tab cialis online|cialis compra usa|cialis cheap 20|cialis australia generic|cialis quick shipment|cialis brand prices|achat de cialis gnrique|cialis 20mg en belgique|take generic cialis|only today cialis generic sale|were to buy cialis online|cialis per nachname bestellen|cialis for sale in cebu|we like it buy cialis generic|about the socialist project|click now low cost cialis|how to take generic cialis|cialis dosage average|click here gerenic cialis|cialis does insurance my|cialis levitra propecia|discount cialis generic cheap|buy cialis aus|brand cialis buy online|visit web site buy cialis us|only best offers find cialis|cialis price per pill 2013|canadian healthcare cialis|cheapest cialis nz|cialis precio farmacia mexico|cialis tadalafil delivery|10203050100 mg cialis|cmprar cialis genericos|can cialis cause weight loss|buy cialis 50|cialis beipackzettel|discount 10 mg generic cialis|cialis online 2 day shipping|cialis deutschland apotheke|cialis reduzierte preis|purchase cialis 5 mg online|cialis 10 o 2|cialis compresse 5 mg prezzo|cialis with priligy|quanto costa cialis da 10 mg|cialis online bestellen wo|cialis safety|i recommend online meds cialis|24 pharmacy cialis|good choice cialis 100mg|brand 10mg cialis price|cialis buy cheap best|cialis generico en colombi|bonuses cialis pharmacy online|cialis generico postepay|generic cialis chewable|cheap 2 5 mg cialis|cialis haltbarkeit|legal buy cialis online|prix du cialis canada|cialis originale italia|good choice cheap cialis 50mg|we like it 5mg cialis generic|generika cialis oral jelly| cialis surrey bc|como comprar cialis en india|enter site buy generic cialis|daily use cialis|20 mg cialis cost|10mg or 20mg cialis|cialis tadalafil 80mg|cialis new york times|preis cialis once a da|usefull link ordering cialis|i recommend cialis cheap buy|cialis generico india|cialis tadalafil kosten|cialis generico en torreon|cialis farmacia acquisto|try it cialis online store|online pharmacy cialis c 40|fast delivery cialis sweden|where can i order cialis cheap|wow next day cialis|cialis 10 mg en andorra|prezzi di cialis uk|cheapest generic cialis soft|is 200mg of cialis too strong|cialis cancer de la prostate|cheap cialis from usa|donde comprar cialis en espa|order cialis online australia|cialis mexico online|discount cialis 32|100mg cialis to buy in uk|cialis usa online paypal|donde comprar cialis 5 mg|best prices for cialis online|just try cheap fast cialis|cialis strips online|enter site rx cialis low price|cialis prix farmacias lila|look there cialis delivery|only now buy cialis uk|discounted cialis online|only here cialis dosage|cialis generique en pharmacie|purchase brand cialis in uk|cialis generic cialis|cialis canadian pharmacy buy|cialis levitra ebay|buy cialis from estonia|cialis dosage sale|cialis and grapefruit juice|buy cialis 25 mg buy now|cialis alle donne|comprar cialis en colombia|usefull link cialis on line|cialis acheter internet|acheter cialis ligne france|cialis omeprazolo|lilly cialis onlin|buy female cialis with paypal|cialis 100mg canada|prix du cialis 5mg en france|cialis non v|precio de cialis en uk|cialis 10 mg espaa|cialis cheapest price 5mg|cialis super acti|compre la pastilla cialis|daily cialis when to take|cialis tabs wholesale|tabs of cialis generic|comprar cialis espaa|cheap cialis on line 5 mg|cialis tadalafil 20mg original|cialis generika 20mg|cialis i migliori|a half cialis 20mg|how much does cialis costs|cialis coupon walmart|cialis fast delivery europe|where to buy generic cialis|levitra sale walmart cialis|cialis eli lilly|side effects of cialis for men|cialis 10 mg daily|cialis 10mg online bestellen|cialis online preise|purchase discount cialis|acquisto cialis reato|generic cialis soft|cialis 20 mg rezept|cialis for sale|we use it get cialis online|buy cialis tennessee online|cialis fast delivery no doctor|come funziona il cialis 20 mg|only for you get cialis online|cialis generique 20 mg|free cialis trial online|medikament cialis 20|american cialis paypal|generic cialis trial size|cipla cialis order|cialis cheap from india|achat cialis en ligne europe|look here cialis 30 mg|price cialis 5 best australia|cialis et tension|qualitygenerics comcialis|cialis mdicament|does cialis work on women|cost of cialis vs levitra|looking for cialis cheap

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *