Gov. pulls trigger, hits education

(John Fensterwald coauthored this article.)

Midyear budget cuts hit California like a tornado on Tuesday, leaving public schools with less damage than anticipated while bearing down on state colleges and universities with full force. Gov. Jerry Brown announced that although state revenues rose, it wasn’t enough to stave off the so-called “trigger cuts” built into this year’s budget.

With revenues more than $2.2 billion below projections, Brown said the state has to cut another $1 billion in spending. Of that, about $328 million will come from K-12 education, which is significantly less than the $1.4 billion worst-case scenario.

There was no such reprieve for higher education; the University of California, California State University, and the state’s community college system will each lose an additional $100 million in the new year.

"We have to live within our means," said Gov. Brown in announcing nearly $1 billion in mid-year cuts. (source:  Governor's press conference) Click to enlarge.
"We have to live within our means," said Gov. Brown in announcing nearly $1 billion in midyear cuts. (Source: Governor's press conference) Click to enlarge.

I want to invoke a Latin phrase here,” said Brown at a press conference in the Capitol. “Nemo dat [quod] non habet; it means no man gives what he does not have. The state cannot give what it does not have.”

Several times during his comments, the governor acknowledged that he’s sensitive to the hardships the reductions will cause, but said the state has to live within its means or it will end up like Greece, Italy, and Spain, countries that overspent to excess and are now unable to climb out of the holes they dug.

Higher ed, higher fees

His argument didn’t sway critics, especially at the three college and university systems, which have already lost billions of dollars in state funding in recent years.

“The governor is the Grinch that stole Christmas,” said Foothill-De Anza Community College District Chancellor Linda Thor, only half jokingly. Although she knew the cuts were a strong probability, Thor said it still means another $2.8 million from her district ($3.3 million if you count the lack of cost-of-living increases), and that’s on top of $24.6 million in cuts over the last three years.

For the rest of the academic year Foothill-De Anza will dig into a rainy day fund established during better times, but that’s running low after several years of stormy economic weather.

What’s more, starting this summer student fees will jump from $36 a credit to $46. That’s far below the rest of the nation, but it’s still nearly $1400 a year for a full-time student, and community colleges have a high percentage of low-income students.

De Anza College awarded financial aid to more students in the current fall quarter than it did to all students in the entire 2010-11 academic year.

California State University students will also be paying more. Last month the Board of Trustees approved a 10 percent fee hike that will kick in next fall. CSU has already raised fees by 29 percent over the past year and a half.

“It is disheartening to say the least when your budget is cut by an initial $650 million, but to face an additional $100 million reduction midyear makes things extremely challenging,” said CSU Chancellor Charles Reed in a statement on the university’s website.

Cuts put brakes on school buses

Funding cuts for K-12 schools under Proposition 98 are a bit fuzzier. The governor and legislative leaders had predicted that revenues would rise $4 billion over the May revise amount.  If revenues were down by the full $4 billion, public schools would have been cut $1.4 billion, or about 3 percent.  Since revenues weren’t that low, schools will see a midyear total cut of $328 million, or about 0.7 percent. That’s an average of $55 per student.

But that’s not exactly how the governor presented it. Brown broke the reductions into two parts: First, a $79.6 million reduction in the basic school funding, called revenue limit funding. That’s the equivalent of about a half-day of school cut, instead of a potential elimination of a whole week.

The second cut is more substantial; a $248 million reduction in home-to-school transportation, in other words, school buses. Taken together, they amount to an average of $55 per student.

However, because school transportation funding primarily affects rural and low-income urban districts ­– and uses an outdated, quirky formula ­– the impact will vary widely among districts, from less than $7 per student in the 19,000-student Antioch Unified, to a whopping $638 per student in the 744-student Southern Humboldt Joint Unified.

Los Angeles Unified, the state’s largest district, which will be absorbing the biggest transportation hit of $38.6 million – $59 per student – announced that it plans to file suit today to halt the cut. The district contends that the cuts would violate a 30-year-old court mandate resulting from a desegregation lawsuit that set up magnet schools and a school choice program; 35,000 students in the district now take buses. At the same time, the alternative – cutting additional services to the classroom ­– would violate the state’s constitutional duty to provide equal educational opportunities.

“LAUSD cannot withstand further budget cuts without adversely impacting the educational benefits offered to its students,” Superintendent John Deasy said in a statement. “We stand with our students to say enough is enough.”

Transportation funding has huge disparities, because it’s based on a decades-old allocation formula that punishes districts that have grown rapidly. California is last in the nation in terms of the proportion of students bused to school: 14 percent, according to Stephen Rhoads, a lobbyist with Strategic Education Services in Sacramento who has focused on the transportation issue.

In his press conference, Brown characterized the transportation cut as flexible, giving districts the ability to backfill bus service by making cuts in other areas. But it’s not as easy as that. Rob Ball, associate superintendent of Twin Rivers Unified in Sacramento County, said that the district already reduced bus routes as much as it could, with some students now walking three miles to a bus stop. Buses also transport high school students through rough neighborhoods in North Sacramento to Grant High; eliminate transportation, and fewer students would show up to school, reducing the state’s tuition reimbursements. This year, said Ball, the district will take the $1 million transportation cut out of its reserves.

Rhoads said that heavily affected districts will lobby legislators to combine the transportation and revenue limit cuts, so that the pain is spread evenly among districts. The Education Coalition, representing the PTA and teachers, administrators, and school boards associations, expressed sympathy. The transportation cut will devastate transportation services and hit poor and neediest students the hardest, it said in a statement. “It will also put at risk the safety and lives of students who will be forced to walk on unsafe roads and through dangerous conditions.”

Author: Kathryn Baron

Kathryn Baron, co-writer of TOP-Ed (Thoughts On Public Education in California), has been covering education in California for about 15 years; most of that time at KQED Public Radio where her reports aired on The California Report as well as various National Public Radio programs. She also wrote for magazines and newspapers before going virtual as producer and editor at The George Lucas Educational Foundation. Kathy grew up in New York in a family of teachers. She moved to California for graduate school and after spending one sunny New Year’s Day riding her bicycle in the foothills, decided to stay. She and her husband live in Belmont. They have two children, one in college and one in high school.

214 thoughts on “Gov. pulls trigger, hits education”

  1. order cialis in new york|acheter cialis lilly france|cialis versandapotheke holland|cialis pas cher montpellier|good choice cialis one a day|mg cialis|discount drug cialis|comprar en india cialis|buying cialis in australia|generic cialis bodybuilding|cialis hilft nicht mehr|online cialis|monthly cost daily cialis|cialis sales au|much cialis can you take|acquista cialis soft|cialis pharmacy sky|cialis achat espagne|can 20mg cialis be split|cialis drug info|cuanto cuesta cialis yaho|cialis keine wirkung|preisvergleich cialis levitr|use cialis term long side|usefull link 50 mg cialis|cheap online cialis generic|try it cialis in the uk|wirkt nicht cialis levitra|price of a 5mg cialis pill|how to order cialis sublingual|generische cialis|cialis gnrique prix|venta de cialis en andorra|buy cialis miami|precio cialis en andorr|cialis health|forum cialis ligne|cialis generic 5mg daily use|cialis money order|cialis soft pillspeople group|cialis en europa|cialis precio peru|cialis 5 mg terapia|cialis for sale australia|en ligne rx pour cialis|lasts mg cialis|treatment of bph with cialis|purchase cialis online now|only for you cialis india|kjp cialis for kvinner|cialis inf|cialis farmacias andorra|only here generic cialis fedex|how cialis works on men|buy brand cialis|order cialis today|link for you cialis overnight|buy cialis europe|india discount prices cialis|cialis 5 mg when to take|campione di cialis tadalafil|only here discount cialis|comprar cialis en ecuador|original cialis sale on line|can i take cialis with lotrel|acheter cialis doctissimo|cialis generique inde|best soft cialis|25 mg cialis online|buy cialis buy paypal|propecia spain cialis levitra|cialis 60 mg cheap|order brand cialis paypal|werking cialis 20 mg|price for cialis 5mg australia|retail pharmacy price cialis|cialis domicilio chile|online cialis soft|cialis for sale in ontario|cialis dose size10 mg cialis|acheter cialis marseille|visit our site price cialis|uk very cheap generic cialis|cialis selbst herstellen|cialis to australia|cialis barato espaa|cialis and citalopram together|cost of cialis per tablet|ordering cialis brand name|cialis ou kamagr|cialis rezeptfrei polen|drug prices cialis|what is order cialis soft tabs|cialis switzerland|cialis prezzi farmacia|cialis soft tabs canada|cialis dose quotidienne|buy one a day cialis|generic cialis next|cialis e impotenza|le mieux vite ordre de cialis|cialis 20 mg packungsgre|cialis prescription best price|lilly icos cialis 5 mg|cialis rezeptfrei 2010|cialis and us online pharmacy|cialis generika per paypal|buy cialis pro|click now cialis buy uk|buy cialis from on line|prix de cialis 20 mg|how much do cialis pills cost|cheaper than cialis|rx cialis para venta|generic cialis overseas|cialis original ohne rezept|is cialis black safe|acheter cialis en belgique|brand 10mg cialis canada|tomar cialis 20 m|we choice cialis usa|acheter cialis legalement|buy mastercard cialis generic|cialis for daly used|cialis fr henne|the best site cialis legal|wow cialis for men|cialis 5 mg cost|buy cialis online from uk|cialis brand prices|average retail price cialis|cialis in der schweiz|cialis generico dosis|cialis non generique|how to take cialis 20mg|cialis generika testen|we like it wholesale cialis|venta cialis costa rica|look here cialis canada|online sale of cialis|the best place info cialis|price for cialis retail|wholesale cialis 50mg|only today cialis iop|cialis reviews forum|buy cialis in mumbai|cialis cheapest|cialis generika 20mg forum|only for you cialis pharmacy|cialis verschreibungspflichtig|cialis dauereinnahme|buy e20 cialis|effets cialis 20mg|gesetzlich kauf cialis|comprar cialis lima peru|cialis 10 mg vendita online|cialis potenzmittel kaufen|cialis in canada only|just try cheap cialis pills|cialis taken together extenze|cialis 5 costo|cialis black generic|cialis kaufen in schweiz|try it cialis for less 20 mg|acheter cialis europe|generico do cialis 5mg|click now drug cialis|cuanto cuesta cialis en espa|cialis 5mg teilen|cialis usa preise|comprar cialis de india|best deals on cialis|vente cialis canad|cialis 10 mg erezione|cialis cuanto dura el efect|cialis kamagra bestelle|cialis prix doctissimo|look there buy branded cialis|cheapest prices of cialis|cialis 2|cialis levitra cost comparison|cialis 50 mg tadalafil|cialis 5 mg tab price|only here cheepest cialis|5 mg original brand cialis|custemer cialis5mg|cialis comprim|cialis online offer|visit web site cialis in spain|cialis del bajo costo|vente de cialis au maroc|vente cialis 5mg|generic cialis versus brand|canadacialis60mg|notice cialis|wow daily cialis for sale|flomax vs cialis bph|buy cialis in usa online|online pharmacy cialis canada|very lowest price for cialis|mdicament cialis performanc|can i take prozac and cialis|cialis 5 mg en bogota|cheapest buy cialis|cialis price daily use|propecia precio cialis levitra|zumo de buy cialis pills|wirkung von cialis 5 mg|cialis prescription in canada|cialis 10mg vs 20m|buy cialis new york online|anyone bought cialis online|cialis 20mg brisbane|order cialis online legal|cialis ou autre produit|questions generic cialis|cialis20mglilly|has anyone used generic cialis|try it generic cialis softtabs|100 mg brand cialis|i use it us cialis|look here canada cialis|cialis torrinomedica|cialis 80|sale daily cialis|try it cialis daily|coste de pldora cialis|href online a cialis online|pharmacie en ligne usa cialis|buy cialis eli lilly|cialis on line from usa|link for you cialis fast|10 mg cialis online|cialis pharmacy blog|brand cialis medication order|cialis tratamiento impotenci|cialis farmacia on line|cialis 10 mg precio espaa|cialis 20 mg price in usa|black cialis best cheap buy|buy cialis directory|generic super cialis liquid|sales cialis 20mg|cialis in apotheke|india cialis safe|cialis 25mg malaysia|just try cialis how much|we like it cialis generic 10mg|cialis arreter|cialis black review

    cialis online
    cheap cialis

    order cialis in new york|acheter cialis lilly france|cialis versandapotheke holland|cialis pas cher montpellier|good choice cialis one a day|mg cialis|discount drug cialis|comprar en india cialis|buying cialis in australia|generic cialis bodybuilding|cialis hilft nicht mehr|online cialis|monthly cost daily cialis|cialis sales au|much cialis can you take|acquista cialis soft|cialis pharmacy sky|cialis achat espagne|can 20mg cialis be split|cialis drug info|cuanto cuesta cialis yaho|cialis keine wirkung|preisvergleich cialis levitr|use cialis term long side|usefull link 50 mg cialis|cheap online cialis generic|try it cialis in the uk|wirkt nicht cialis levitra|price of a 5mg cialis pill|how to order cialis sublingual|generische cialis|cialis gnrique prix|venta de cialis en andorra|buy cialis miami|precio cialis en andorr|cialis health|forum cialis ligne|cialis generic 5mg daily use|cialis money order|cialis soft pillspeople group|cialis en europa|cialis precio peru|cialis 5 mg terapia|cialis for sale australia|en ligne rx pour cialis|lasts mg cialis|treatment of bph with cialis|purchase cialis online now|only for you cialis india|kjp cialis for kvinner|cialis inf|cialis farmacias andorra|only here generic cialis fedex|how cialis works on men|buy brand cialis|order cialis today|link for you cialis overnight|buy cialis europe|india discount prices cialis|cialis 5 mg when to take|campione di cialis tadalafil|only here discount cialis|comprar cialis en ecuador|original cialis sale on line|can i take cialis with lotrel|acheter cialis doctissimo|cialis generique inde|best soft cialis|25 mg cialis online|buy cialis buy paypal|propecia spain cialis levitra|cialis 60 mg cheap|order brand cialis paypal|werking cialis 20 mg|price for cialis 5mg australia|retail pharmacy price cialis|cialis domicilio chile|online cialis soft|cialis for sale in ontario|cialis dose size10 mg cialis|acheter cialis marseille|visit our site price cialis|uk very cheap generic cialis|cialis selbst herstellen|cialis to australia|cialis barato espaa|cialis and citalopram together|cost of cialis per tablet|ordering cialis brand name|cialis ou kamagr|cialis rezeptfrei polen|drug prices cialis|what is order cialis soft tabs|cialis switzerland|cialis prezzi farmacia|cialis soft tabs canada|cialis dose quotidienne|buy one a day cialis|generic cialis next|cialis e impotenza|le mieux vite ordre de cialis|cialis 20 mg packungsgre|cialis prescription best price|lilly icos cialis 5 mg|cialis rezeptfrei 2010|cialis and us online pharmacy|cialis generika per paypal|buy cialis pro|click now cialis buy uk|buy cialis from on line|prix de cialis 20 mg|how much do cialis pills cost|cheaper than cialis|rx cialis para venta|generic cialis overseas|cialis original ohne rezept|is cialis black safe|acheter cialis en belgique|brand 10mg cialis canada|tomar cialis 20 m|we choice cialis usa|acheter cialis legalement|buy mastercard cialis generic|cialis for daly used|cialis fr henne|the best site cialis legal|wow cialis for men|cialis 5 mg cost|buy cialis online from uk|cialis brand prices|average retail price cialis|cialis in der schweiz|cialis generico dosis|cialis non generique|how to take cialis 20mg|cialis generika testen|we like it wholesale cialis|venta cialis costa rica|look here cialis canada|online sale of cialis|the best place info cialis|price for cialis retail|wholesale cialis 50mg|only today cialis iop|cialis reviews forum|buy cialis in mumbai|cialis cheapest|cialis generika 20mg forum|only for you cialis pharmacy|cialis verschreibungspflichtig|cialis dauereinnahme|buy e20 cialis|effets cialis 20mg|gesetzlich kauf cialis|comprar cialis lima peru|cialis 10 mg vendita online|cialis potenzmittel kaufen|cialis in canada only|just try cheap cialis pills|cialis taken together extenze|cialis 5 costo|cialis black generic|cialis kaufen in schweiz|try it cialis for less 20 mg|acheter cialis europe|generico do cialis 5mg|click now drug cialis|cuanto cuesta cialis en espa|cialis 5mg teilen|cialis usa preise|comprar cialis de india|best deals on cialis|vente cialis canad|cialis 10 mg erezione|cialis cuanto dura el efect|cialis kamagra bestelle|cialis prix doctissimo|look there buy branded cialis|cheapest prices of cialis|cialis 2|cialis levitra cost comparison|cialis 50 mg tadalafil|cialis 5 mg tab price|only here cheepest cialis|5 mg original brand cialis|custemer cialis5mg|cialis comprim|cialis online offer|visit web site cialis in spain|cialis del bajo costo|vente de cialis au maroc|vente cialis 5mg|generic cialis versus brand|canadacialis60mg|notice cialis|wow daily cialis for sale|flomax vs cialis bph|buy cialis in usa online|online pharmacy cialis canada|very lowest price for cialis|mdicament cialis performanc|can i take prozac and cialis|cialis 5 mg en bogota|cheapest buy cialis|cialis price daily use|propecia precio cialis levitra|zumo de buy cialis pills|wirkung von cialis 5 mg|cialis prescription in canada|cialis 10mg vs 20m|buy cialis new york online|anyone bought cialis online|cialis 20mg brisbane|order cialis online legal|cialis ou autre produit|questions generic cialis|cialis20mglilly|has anyone used generic cialis|try it generic cialis softtabs|100 mg brand cialis|i use it us cialis|look here canada cialis|cialis torrinomedica|cialis 80|sale daily cialis|try it cialis daily|coste de pldora cialis|href online a cialis online|pharmacie en ligne usa cialis|buy cialis eli lilly|cialis on line from usa|link for you cialis fast|10 mg cialis online|cialis pharmacy blog|brand cialis medication order|cialis tratamiento impotenci|cialis farmacia on line|cialis 10 mg precio espaa|cialis 20 mg price in usa|black cialis best cheap buy|buy cialis directory|generic super cialis liquid|sales cialis 20mg|cialis in apotheke|india cialis safe|cialis 25mg malaysia|just try cialis how much|we like it cialis generic 10mg|cialis arreter|cialis black review

  2. Excellent post but I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this topic? I’d be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *