Given more control over how they could spend state money, school districts not surprisingly chose survival over experimentation. And if legislators want otherwise – to encourage districts to innovate or target money on low-achieving students – then they should be more explicit about their intentions.
That was the main finding and chief recommendation of a study of districts’ flexible spending last year by the RAND Corporation and researchers with the University of California. The results are consistent with annual surveys by the Legislative Analyst’s Office the past two years.
The study – also a survey, of chief financial officers in 223 districts – diagnosed how districts spent their share of $4.5 billion in previously earmarked spending. That encompassed 40 of 60 categorical programs and slightly less than a quarter of the $19 billion in total restricted spending that the Legislature made flexible in 2009.
Longtime advocates of unloosing control from Sacramento had speculated that districts might use deregulated spending to “make focused investments in new instructional approaches to meet local needs” or push decision-making to the school site level. They wondered whether vocal, well-organized groups – educated parents or unions – would dominate control over spending, aggravating disparities in student spending.
But none of this happened to a great extent. (There is an interesting experiment on school-based budgeting in Los Angeles Unified and Twin Rivers Unified, which contributors to TOP-Ed have written about here and here.) Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger cut categorical programs 20 percent in 2009 when instituting flexibility, and total K-12 spending has been cut 18 percent since 2007-08. As a result, districts “swept” restricted dollars into their general funds in order to keep solvent and prevent additional layoffs, the study found. Money that had been earmarked for teacher and staff training and for general school improvement was largely diverted. Adult education was cut severely in many districts that had the programs.
“Hopes of some advocates that local control would spur widespread innovation or a new focus on classroom improvements simply proved unrealistic,” the study’s co-author, Bruce Fuller, a co-director of the Policy Analysis for California Education (PACE), said in a news release.
However, the study also found that “about one-third (of districts) reported that aligning spending with ‘school improvement goals’ was a high priority, and a few reported allocating newly flexible dollars to instructional reforms.” The latter were mainly urban school districts.
Lost accountability
The study has implications moving forward. Gov. Jerry Brown has proposed shifting most categorical dollars, including the money already flexed, into a weighted student funding formula that would shift significant spending to low-income students and English learners. Brown’s proposal has run into opposition based on the distribution formula. But advocates for poor children also have called on Brown to include assurances that the extra dollars would be spent on them and that local parent and English learner school committees be given a role in overseeing the dollars. The groups, which included the Education Trust-West and Public Advocates, stated their position in a June 14 letter to Brown.
Another approach could be a block grant, in which districts have latitude to spend as they choose within parameters, such as designating money broadly for professional development. Assemblymember Julia Brownley, who chairs the Assembly Education Committee, took that approach in AB 18, a variation of a weighted student formula.
RAND and the LAO had to rely on district surveys, because the state didn’t force districts to report how they spent formerly restricted dollars. The RAND-UC report recommends that the state Department of Education require this and that legislators require that flexibility be evaluated to determine which students and which programs benefited and which did not. Among the questions worth asking:
- “What happens to programs whose funds are most often swept up, such as art and music?”
- “How do changes in adult education funding affect communities and other institutions providing such services?”
a quick payday loan pay pay loans american loans [url=https://cashloansonline.us.org/#]lead loans[/url]
prescription price comparison
online pharmacies canada
web medical information
canada drug pharmacy
service connected erectile dysfunction
best erectile pills
top erectile strength products
best erectile pills
erectile damage
erectile enhancement pills
erectile remedies
best erectile pills
erectile tools
erection pills
is erectile dysfunction psychological
best erectile dysfunction pills
erectile stamina
buy erectile dysfunction meds online
erectile implants
buy erectile dysfunction pills online
lowest viagra price how to get viagra viagra pills [url=http://viagrapfhze.com/#]generic viagra online[/url]
viagra on line cheap viagra pills order viagra [url=http://viagrapfhze.com/#]order viagra[/url]
dealing with erectile dysfunction
erectile pills without a doctor prescription
erectile ointment
cheapest ed drugs
how erectile dysfunction affects reproduction
erectile pills canada
erectile dysfunction symptoms
erectile pills over the counter
generic viagra buy viagra viagra prescription [url=http://viagrapfhze.com/#]buy viagra online[/url]
antidepressant without erectile dysfunction
erectile dysfunction medications
do erectile dysfunction pills really work
best erectile dysfunction medication
Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point. You obviously know what youre talking about, why throw away your intelligence on just posting videos to your blog when you could be giving us something enlightening to read?
name brand viagra online viagra dosage viagra overnight shipping [url=http://viagracefo.com/#]viagra sale[/url]
erectile dysfunction doctors
best erectile dysfunction medication
10 best erectile
new drugs for ed
viagra professional viagra order viagra online stores [url=http://viagraveikd.com/#]how to get viagra[/url]
buy real viagra online discount viagra viagra sales [url=http://viagraveikd.com/#]branded viagra[/url]
erectile triggers
ed drugs over the counter
erectile disorder articles
erectile enhancement pills
cialis 5mg tadalafil cialis cialis coupon [url=http://cialisovnnc.com/#]no prescription cialis[/url]
for erectile health and better blood flow
buy erectile dysfunction meds online
erectile enhancement products
best erectile dysfunction medication
erectile jelly
buy erectile dysfunction medications online
erectile aliments
best erectile pills
generic viagra online pharmacy discount viagra buy cheap brand viagra [url=http://viagrapbna.com/#]viagra no prescription[/url]
sildenafil viagra buy viagra generic viagra rx [url=http://viagraazmhj.com/#]viagra online[/url]
cialis cost buy tadalafil 20mg price order cialis [url=http://cialisovnnc.com/#]tadalafil generic[/url]