Dismissal bill falters in Assembly

With teachers and organized labor rallying against what they called an unnecessary attack on their rights, a bill that would make it easier to fire teachers and administrators accused of serious sexual and violent offenses against children failed to pass the Assembly Education Committee on Wednesday. Sen. Alex Padilla’s controversial SB 1530 will be dead for the session unless he can persuade one more Democrat to reverse positions within the next week .

The bill had bipartisan support in the Senate, where it passed 33-4, but, in a test of strength by the California Teachers Association, only one Democrat, Education Committee Chairwoman Julia Brownley, and all four Republicans backed it in the crucial committee vote. The other six Democrats either voted buy clomid online against it (Tom Ammiano, San Francisco; Joan Buchanan, San Ramon) or didn’t vote (Betsy Butler, El Segundo; Wilmer Carter, Rialto; Mike Eng, Alhambra; and Das Williams, Santa Barbara).

The bill follows shocking incidents of sexual abuse in Los Angeles Unified and elsewhere, the worst of which involved Mark Berndt, 61, who’s been accused of 23 lewd acts against children at Miramonte Elementary in LAUSD. Padilla, a Democrat from Van Nuys, said SB 1530 responded to complaints from superintendents and school board members that it takes too long and is too expensive to fire teachers facing even the worst of charges. Rather than go through hearings and potential appeals, LAUSD paid Berndt $40,000, including legal fees, to drop the appeal of his firing.

Under current law, dismissal cases against teachers and administrators go before a three-person Commission on Professional Competence, which includes two teachers and buy amoxil online an administrative law judge. Its decision can be appealed in Superior Court.

Narrow band of ‘egregious’ cases

SB 1530 would have carved out a narrow band of exceptions applying to “egregious or serious” offenses by teachers and administrators involving drugs, sex, and violence against children. In those cases, the competence commission would be replaced by a hearing before an administrative law judge whose strictly advisory recommendation would go to the local school board for a final decision, appealable in court.

The bill also would have made admissible evidence of misconduct older than four years. Berndt had prior reports of abuse that had been removed from his file,  because a statute of limitations in the teachers contract in LAUSD prohibited their use.

School boards already have final say over dismissal of school employees other than teachers and administrators, so the bill would extend that to efforts to remove “a very creepy teacher” from the classroom,” as Oakley Union Elementary School District Superintendent Richard Rogers put it. “What is more fundamental than locally elected officials responsible for hiring and dismissal?” he asked.

The bill has the support of the administrators and school boards associations, Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, and the LAUSD president, Monica Garcia, who described her fellow board members as “seven union-friendly Democrats” who want to “get rid of people who will hurt our children.”

Current law works

But Warren Fletcher, president of United Teachers Los Angeles, countered that “SB 1530 solves nothing, places teachers at unfair risk, and diverts attention from the real accountability issues at LAUSD.” Turning the tables, Fletcher, CTA President Dean Vogel, and others have filed statements with the state Commission on Teacher Credentialing to investigate Superintendent John Deasy’s handling of misconduct allegations in the district.

The argument that current law works resonated with Buchanan, who served two decades on the San Ramon Valley School Board. Calling the bill “intellectually dishonest” because nothing can prevent another Miramonte from happening, she said, “We never had problems dismissing employees.” She acknowledged that the “long, expensive dismissal process” needs to be streamlined, but the bill doesn’t get it right. A teacher at a school in her legislative district was accused of sexual misconduct by a student who got a bad grade. That teacher “deserves due process.”

The two teachers on the Commission on Professional Competence provide professional judgment that’s needed to protect the rights of employees, said Patricia Rucker, a CTA lobbyist who’s also a State Board of Education member. “We do value the right to participate and adjudicate standards for holding teachers accountable,” she said.

Fletcher said that school boards would be subject to parental pressure in emotionally charged cases, and, as a policy body, should not be given judicial power. Assemblyman Ammiano, a former teacher, agreed. “A school board is not the one to make the decision,” he said.

Julia  Brownley said that she too was concerned about false charges against teachers but would support the bill, for it “will give districts tools” for rare circumstances. The bill would make the dismissal process more efficient and definitive. And she agreed with Padilla that the bill ensured due process for teachers, who’d be allowed to present their case, with witnesses, before an administrative judge and appeal an adverse decision to Superior Court.

Oakley Superintendent Richards said that the CTA misstated what SB 1530 does and “has taken such an extreme position on this issue that they have lost credibility.” The union’s real fear is that the bill will be “a nose under the camel’s tent” to change the dismissal process for all teachers. And that, he said, is unfounded.

Padilla was to have issued a statement last night on the setback in the committee but didn’t. Update: Padilla issued a statement this morning that reads, in part:  “SB 1530 was narrowly crafted to focus only on cases in which school employees are accused of sex, violence, or drug use with children. It is difficult to understand why anyone would oppose a measure to protect children. It is very disappointing.”

Author: John Fensterwald - Educated Guess

John Fensterwald, a journalist at the Silicon Valley Education Foundation, edits and co-writes "Thoughts on Public Education in California" (www.TOPed.org), one of the leading sources of California education policy reporting and opinion, which he founded in 2009. For 11 years before that, John wrote editorials for the Mercury News in San Jose, with a focus on education. He worked as a reporter, news editor and opinion editor for three newspapers in New Hampshire for two decades before receiving a Knight Fellowship at Stanford University in 1997 and heading West shortly thereafter. His wife is an elementary school teacher and his daughter attends the University California at Davis.

94 thoughts on “Dismissal bill falters in Assembly”

  1. try it cialis dosecialis como salen inglaterrawhat is generic cialis 10mgcialis vegetalbuy one day cialiscialis and trimix togetherwe choice cialis usnow cialis payment paypalcialis 5 mg salefor sale cialis tabletscanadian cialisbilliges cialis bestellenaustralia cialis buycialis 5mg preise osterreichcout du cialisil cialis generico e sicuro?buy cheapest daily cialiswow womans cialiscialis online forucialis nuchtern einnehmencialis kanada bestellen onlineosu cialis generico forum,enter site cialis tabsbuy cialis in sohofarmacia uk cialisprezzo cialis da 5 mgachat cialis 2 5 mgcialis 20 mlacheter cialis suisscialis online express200 cialiswe like it cialis low pricegeneric cialis potencycialis causes me headachecounterfeit cialis ukordering cialis onlinecialis hearing lossblog how to order cialiscialis indiegenerika cialis levitracialis miglior prezzo italiaprescription cialis canadacialis 5 mg generikacialis historicialis per duratacialis discounts and couponscialis or genericcialis free printable coupongeneric cheap cialis online5mg cialis onlinekaufen cialis nachnahmepurchase cialis no rxwow buy cialis australiawe like it generic cialis usacialis ou autresforo cialis genericosventa de cialis en iquiquecialis online generic eumail order cialis from canadahow to buy cialiscialis canada buy onlinecialis kaufen in hamburgsite once daily cialis costtry it buy 5 mg cialisgenerico para 20 mg cialiscialis online italicialis with paypalexpress cialis deliverypurchase cialis prescriptioncialis levitra paypalcialis tabs 20mgvendo cialis toscanacialis dove acquistarecialis cheap overseascialis venta 2010cialis generico en mexico dfcialis 20mg tadalafil preisecialis prices comparisonlook there lowest price cialischeapest cialis for saleusefull link brand name cialiscialis 5 mg 28 stvendo cialis generico chilebipolar specialist low pricecialis for men costou acheter du cialis au canadacialis daily us pricecialis extenze togethercialis pillola costocialis e ipertensione lievdonde compro cialis 10try it cialis mail ordercialis deutschland kaufpaypal cialis descuentocanada cialis generic onlinecialis okay fur frauengeneric cialis melbournecialis commercialbuy low cost cialis soft tabcialis online offercialis 20 mg 4 tablcialis senza ricetta svizzercialis costs,try it non pescription cialiscialis en ligne du canadacialis 5mg tablettencialis pastilla oralil cialis fa dimagrirepurchase cialis canada onlinecheap cialis softonly here cialis mail ordercialis 50mg buyachat de cialis non generiquewe like it cialis to ordercialis hace efectlook there get cialis cheapcialis generic lowest pricecialis on line basso costocialis 4cpr riv 20mgcialis chennaiwe recommend soft tab cialisprix medicament cialis marocnew cialis daily dosecialis pill ukonly now cialis 2.5 mgprice cialis daily use 5mgcialis comlrar con mastercardcan you two take 10mg cialisquanto costa cialis originalemedicament cialis generiquecialis campione libero ukcialis generico 5 mg prezzgeneric cialis online 10mgbuy cialis online soft tabsbest price on cialis 20mg online order cialiswow approval cialis fdawant to purchase cialisdosaggio cialisachetez cialis profesionalcialis comprar en farmaciablack buy generic cialiscialis daily in what mgscialis frankreich rezeptfreicialis angebotcialis laboratoire lillytarif cialis andorrecheapest cialis availablecialis expirycialis drug prescriptioncompra de los cialisenter site cialis soft tabscialis liquid formcialis generika online kaufencompri cialis in farmacielevitra 2cialiscost cialiscialis daily use pricecompare prices on cialiscialis trial samples canadafree cialis sample pack in usageneric cialis salescialis-pille-kaufvendita farmaci online cialislevitra cialis professionnelbrand cialis from uksoft cialis now cheapcialis generico funziona?buy cialis fast deliverycialis effettfollow link best cialiscialis da europalaboratoire lilly cialiscialis que es yahoosuper cialis ukbuy cialis in sebokengcialis 33 annicialis uk the cheapestcialis try before buywhats best to take cialisonline cialis kaufencanada pharmacy cialis onlineonly now best quality cialiscialis price 4 tabletsback cialis guarantee moneysito cialis genericogeneric cialis united stateslook there buy generic cialison line cost of cialiscialis generico torinocialis prise en chargeamerican cialiscialis pas cher a pariscialis kaufen frankreiccialis 40 mg online australiaonly best offers mexico cialisgenerico de cialis en perucialis pillen deutschlandaffairs cialis veteransarticles on generic cialisclick here soft tab cialisonly today cialis 10 mgonly now canadain cialiscomprar cialis medicamentocialis bestellen in frankreichpills price india cialisorder safe generic cialiscialis acheter en belgiqueis cialis by prescription onlycialis edemacialis daily costuser reviews of cialishow much cialis costtadalafil cialis best usagecheap cialis from ukis cialis generic legal in uscialis pfizer achatacquisto cialis originalcialis gelenkschmerzenthe best site cialis australiacorporate finance specialistcialis impotenza o levitrventa cialis soft cubanowow buy cialis mexicowhere can i get cialisfollow link online us cialisbest price online daily cialiscialis kaufen shopbuy cialis 5mg tabletscialis switzerlandwhere to buy cheap cialiscialis overnight delivery usacialis quanto custacheap cialis online 5b mgthe best choice cialis on lineforo cialis onlinecialis for cheapwill cialis available genericcialis 5 mg au canadacialis 2 comprimescialis 7.5 mgcialis and pregnancyingredient in cialisbuy over counter cialiscialis 20 posologiadverse effects cialisdonde compra cialis en madridwe choice cialis online indiaonly here buy cialis in canadacost of 20mg cialis

    http://cialispqh.com/ – cialis online

    generic cialis online

    try it cialis dosecialis como salen inglaterrawhat is generic cialis 10mgcialis vegetalbuy one day cialiscialis and trimix togetherwe choice cialis usnow cialis payment paypalcialis 5 mg salefor sale cialis tabletscanadian cialisbilliges cialis bestellenaustralia cialis buycialis 5mg preise osterreichcout du cialisil cialis generico e sicuro?buy cheapest daily cialiswow womans cialiscialis online forucialis nuchtern einnehmencialis kanada bestellen onlineosu cialis generico forum,enter site cialis tabsbuy cialis in sohofarmacia uk cialisprezzo cialis da 5 mgachat cialis 2 5 mgcialis 20 mlacheter cialis suisscialis online express200 cialiswe like it cialis low pricegeneric cialis potencycialis causes me headachecounterfeit cialis ukordering cialis onlinecialis hearing lossblog how to order cialiscialis indiegenerika cialis levitracialis miglior prezzo italiaprescription cialis canadacialis 5 mg generikacialis historicialis per duratacialis discounts and couponscialis or genericcialis free printable coupongeneric cheap cialis online5mg cialis onlinekaufen cialis nachnahmepurchase cialis no rxwow buy cialis australiawe like it generic cialis usacialis ou autresforo cialis genericosventa de cialis en iquiquecialis online generic eumail order cialis from canadahow to buy cialiscialis canada buy onlinecialis kaufen in hamburgsite once daily cialis costtry it buy 5 mg cialisgenerico para 20 mg cialiscialis online italicialis with paypalexpress cialis deliverypurchase cialis prescriptioncialis levitra paypalcialis tabs 20mgvendo cialis toscanacialis dove acquistarecialis cheap overseascialis venta 2010cialis generico en mexico dfcialis 20mg tadalafil preisecialis prices comparisonlook there lowest price cialischeapest cialis for saleusefull link brand name cialiscialis 5 mg 28 stvendo cialis generico chilebipolar specialist low pricecialis for men costou acheter du cialis au canadacialis daily us pricecialis extenze togethercialis pillola costocialis e ipertensione lievdonde compro cialis 10try it cialis mail ordercialis deutschland kaufpaypal cialis descuentocanada cialis generic onlinecialis okay fur frauengeneric cialis melbournecialis commercialbuy low cost cialis soft tabcialis online offercialis 20 mg 4 tablcialis senza ricetta svizzercialis costs,try it non pescription cialiscialis en ligne du canadacialis 5mg tablettencialis pastilla oralil cialis fa dimagrirepurchase cialis canada onlinecheap cialis softonly here cialis mail ordercialis 50mg buyachat de cialis non generiquewe like it cialis to ordercialis hace efectlook there get cialis cheapcialis generic lowest pricecialis on line basso costocialis 4cpr riv 20mgcialis chennaiwe recommend soft tab cialisprix medicament cialis marocnew cialis daily dosecialis pill ukonly now cialis 2.5 mgprice cialis daily use 5mgcialis comlrar con mastercardcan you two take 10mg cialisquanto costa cialis originalemedicament cialis generiquecialis campione libero ukcialis generico 5 mg prezzgeneric cialis online 10mgbuy cialis online soft tabsbest price on cialis 20mg online order cialiswow approval cialis fdawant to purchase cialisdosaggio cialisachetez cialis profesionalcialis comprar en farmaciablack buy generic cialiscialis daily in what mgscialis frankreich rezeptfreicialis angebotcialis laboratoire lillytarif cialis andorrecheapest cialis availablecialis expirycialis drug prescriptioncompra de los cialisenter site cialis soft tabscialis liquid formcialis generika online kaufencompri cialis in farmacielevitra 2cialiscost cialiscialis daily use pricecompare prices on cialiscialis trial samples canadafree cialis sample pack in usageneric cialis salescialis-pille-kaufvendita farmaci online cialislevitra cialis professionnelbrand cialis from uksoft cialis now cheapcialis generico funziona?buy cialis fast deliverycialis effettfollow link best cialiscialis da europalaboratoire lilly cialiscialis que es yahoosuper cialis ukbuy cialis in sebokengcialis 33 annicialis uk the cheapestcialis try before buywhats best to take cialisonline cialis kaufencanada pharmacy cialis onlineonly now best quality cialiscialis price 4 tabletsback cialis guarantee moneysito cialis genericogeneric cialis united stateslook there buy generic cialison line cost of cialiscialis generico torinocialis prise en chargeamerican cialiscialis pas cher a pariscialis kaufen frankreiccialis 40 mg online australiaonly best offers mexico cialisgenerico de cialis en perucialis pillen deutschlandaffairs cialis veteransarticles on generic cialisclick here soft tab cialisonly today cialis 10 mgonly now canadain cialiscomprar cialis medicamentocialis bestellen in frankreichpills price india cialisorder safe generic cialiscialis acheter en belgiqueis cialis by prescription onlycialis edemacialis daily costuser reviews of cialishow much cialis costtadalafil cialis best usagecheap cialis from ukis cialis generic legal in uscialis pfizer achatacquisto cialis originalcialis gelenkschmerzenthe best site cialis australiacorporate finance specialistcialis impotenza o levitrventa cialis soft cubanowow buy cialis mexicowhere can i get cialisfollow link online us cialisbest price online daily cialiscialis kaufen shopbuy cialis 5mg tabletscialis switzerlandwhere to buy cheap cialiscialis overnight delivery usacialis quanto custacheap cialis online 5b mgthe best choice cialis on lineforo cialis onlinecialis for cheapwill cialis available genericcialis 5 mg au canadacialis 2 comprimescialis 7.5 mgcialis and pregnancyingredient in cialisbuy over counter cialiscialis 20 posologiadverse effects cialisdonde compra cialis en madridwe choice cialis online indiaonly here buy cialis in canadacost of 20mg cialis

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *